From review to working tool

What does an expert review include?

A useful expert review is not a long list of loose opinions. It is a working tool that shows what you should improve, why it matters and how the team can move forward.

7 min read

A clear scope

The report really begins before the review itself. Target audiences, business goals, key user needs and the most important journeys must be clarified. Without that, the review quickly becomes broad, arbitrary and less useful.

A standard assignment from ekspertevaluering.no covers one digital service and up to two key user journeys, on desktop and mobile where relevant.

Concrete findings in the right context

Every important finding should answer four questions:

  1. What is the problem?A precise description of the situation, preferably with a screenshot.
  2. Why does it matter?The consequence for the user's task, trust, understanding or progress.
  3. How important is it?A priority based on the consequence and the problem's position in the user journey.
  4. How could it be resolved?One or more realistic recommendations for the team to consider.

Priorities that can be explained

Not all findings are equally important. A typo in secondary help text and a blocker in the payment step should not be presented as equally serious simply because both appear in the report.

Priority should reflect the severity of the consequence, how central the situation is and how likely users are to encounter the problem. The reasoning matters more than the score.

Proposed solutions, not criticism alone

A report that only points out faults transfers the problem to the team. Good recommendations make the available options clearer. Sometimes one solution is obvious. At other times, the report should describe several directions and explain the differences.

From problem to solution

“Next” is so close to the final page number that users can easily press the wrong control.

Recommendation: Separate navigation actions from the page numbers and use touch targets of at least 44 × 44 pixels. Give “Next” a distinct shape and position.

A shared presentation of the findings

The report is presented to the people who will make decisions, design or continue building the service. The presentation makes room to clarify technical constraints, internal knowledge and nuances that were not visible from the outside.

The aim is for the team to leave with a shared understanding of the most important problems and a concrete list of what should be improved.

What the standard delivery includes

  • kick-off meeting
  • expert review of one digital service
  • review of up to two user journeys
  • desktop and mobile where relevant
  • report with prioritised recommendations
  • presentation of the findings

Usability testing, a full WCAG audit, additional markets or particularly extensive user journeys can be added after a short clarification.

The report should be ready to use immediately

Your team should be able to turn findings into tasks, discuss the proposed solutions and begin improving the service on the same day the report is presented. You should not have to purchase another project to understand what the report means.

If you need help implementing the recommendations, that help is available. But the expert review stands on its own.

Professional foundation

The assessments draw on more than 15 years of experience with digital products, established interaction design and usability principles, and the specific context of each service. See also ISO 9241-11 on usability and Nielsen Norman Group's heuristic evaluation workbook.

Do you have a service I should review?

Request an expert review

Briefly tell me which service you would like reviewed and which questions you want answered. I will reply with a proposed scope, delivery time and price.

Keep reading