The method, in brief

What is a UX expert review?

A UX expert review is a systematic assessment of a digital service, carried out by a specialist with experience in UX, design and product development. The aim is to identify specific problems, explain their consequences and recommend realistic improvements.

8 min read

In brief

In an expert review, a UX specialist works through your website, app or service as a critical first-time user. At the same time, the complete experience is assessed through the eyes of a senior product designer: What is the user trying to achieve? What do they expect to happen? Where does the interface fail to meet that expectation?

This is neither a test of personal taste nor an automated checklist. A useful expert review combines established usability principles with knowledge of the target audience, business goals, technology and the context in which the service is used.

What is reviewed?

The review follows the most important tasks your users need to complete. The details depend on the service, but the assessment usually covers:

  • the first impression and whether the purpose of the service is clear
  • navigation, information architecture and how easily users can find their way
  • critical user journeys, forms, registration and payment
  • content, language, choices and clear next steps
  • confirmations, error messages, empty states and interruptions
  • mobile behaviour, responsiveness and basic accessibility

Usability is about more than making an interface look tidy. ISO defines usability in terms of how effectively, efficiently and satisfactorily specified users can achieve specified goals in a specified context of use. The context must therefore be part of the assessment.

How the review works

  1. We define the scope. In a short meeting, we clarify the audiences, business goals, user needs and journeys that matter most.
  2. I review the service. I follow the agreed journeys on relevant screen sizes and also examine what happens when something goes wrong.
  3. I document and prioritise the findings. Screenshots, explanations and proposed solutions are collected in a report your team can work from.
  4. I present the findings. We review the report together, clarify nuances and discuss what you should address first.

What a useful finding looks like

Weak advice might say “make the form more intuitive”. It tells you neither where the problem lies nor what the team should do. A useful finding is more precise:

Example finding

An important requirement only appears after the form has been submitted.

Consequence: The user has already completed the entire form before learning that a detail or a specific format is missing.

Recommendation: Show the requirement beside the field before submission. If an error occurs, move focus to the relevant field without removing any other answers.

Context makes the difference. The team learns not only that something is wrong, but where the problem occurs, who it affects and which changes could resolve it.

This is not the same as usability testing

An expert review is carried out by a specialist. Usability testing shows how people in the target audience actually understand and use the service. The methods answer different questions and complement one another.

An expert review is not automatically a full accessibility audit, a technical test, an analysis of traffic data or a complete redesign. Those activities may be relevant, but they must be agreed and delivered as separate parts of the work.

Read the detailed comparison in Expert review or usability testing: which should you choose?

When is an expert review useful?

The method is particularly useful when you know something is not working but do not know why; when the team has become too familiar with the service; or before investing in a major redesign. It can be applied to an early prototype, an established service or a product approaching launch.

There must be enough of the service to assess real choices, actions and feedback. If the biggest questions concern what should be built or who the service is for, user research and product strategy will usually be a better place to start.

Professional foundation

The assessments draw on more than 15 years of experience with digital products, established interaction design and usability principles, and the specific context of each service. See also ISO 9241-11 on usability and Nielsen Norman Group's heuristic evaluation workbook.

Do you have a service I should review?

Request an expert review

Briefly tell me which service you would like reviewed and which questions you want answered. I will reply with a proposed scope, delivery time and price.

Keep reading